Modern Russian historiography on pan-Turkism: Issues, narratives and research perspectives
https://doi.org/10.25206/2542-0488-2026-11-1-46-54
EDN: CVEQII
Abstract
The article critically examines contemporary Russian historiography on Pan-Turkism from 2000 to 2024, identifying key thematic clusters, methodological trends, and unresolved debates. Through a combination of bibliometric analysis and qualitative content evaluation, the study reveals a marked increase in scholarly output after 2015, closely tied to fluctuations in Russo-Turkish relations. The analysis distinguishes three dominant interpretive frameworks: securitization narratives framing Pan-Turkism as a geopolitical threat, cultural-historical approaches emphasizing identity formation, and policy-oriented studies analyzing Turkey's regional influence. Methodologically, the field remains divided between traditional diplomatic history and emerging interdisciplinary perspectives, with only limited engagement with digital humanities or postcolonial theory. A persistent tension is observed between essentialist interpretations reproducing imperial security discourses and more nuanced studies deconstructing the “Turkic world” concept. The article highlights significant regional asymmetries–while Volga-Ural and Crimean case studies abound, Central Asian perspectives remain underrepresented. The conclusion outlines promising research directions, including comparative studies of Turkic identity politics, critical reassessment of archival narratives, and analysis of digital media's role in Pan-Turkic mobilization. This meta-analysis contributes to broader discussions about decolonizing Eurasian studies and the evolving relationship between academic production and foreign policy discourses in post-Soviet scholarship.
Keywords
Russian historiography,
Turkism,
pan-Turkism,
Russian-Turkish relations,
foreign and domestic policy of Turkey,
neo-Ottomanism,
neo-Turkism,
collective Turkism
Supporting agencies: The study is supported by the Russian Science Foundation project no. 24-28-00188 “Pan-Islamism and pan-Turkism: Historical, modern and predictive discourse in persons and events”, https://rscf.ru/project/24-28-00188/.
About the Authors
M. M. Gumerov
Moscow City University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
GUMEROV Marsel Marsovich, Applicant at the History Department, Institute of Humanities; Project Researcher of the RSF № 24-28-00188 of the Linguistics University of Nizhny Novgorod
Moscow
Ju. N. Guseva
Moscow City University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
GUSEVA Yulia Nikolaevna, Doctor of Historical Sciences, Professor of the History Department, Institute of Humanities
Moscow
AuthorID (RSCI): 306741
References
1. Sözer B., Sakhi Z. An overview of research methods and topics used in Turkological studies. Turkic Studies Journal. 2024. Vol. 6, no. 3. P. 196–218. DOI: 10.32523/2664-5157-2024-3-196218.
2. Vasil’yeva S. A. Pantyurkizm na sovremennom etape: teoreticheskaya baza i prakticheskaya deyatel’nost’ [Modern state of pan-Turkism: theoretical foundation and practical activity]. Sotsium i vlast’. Society and Power. 2011. No. 3 (31). P. 75–78. EDN: ONSIID. (In Russ.).
3. Ivanova V. V. Speloye yabloko. Idealy pantyurkizma i identifikatsionnyy sinkretizm [Ripe apple. The ideals of PanTurkism and identification syncretism]. Aziya i Afrika segodnya. Asia and Africa Today. 2012. No. 1. P. 65–71. EDN: OTRMXJ. (In Russ.).
4. Chervonnaya S. M., Gilyazov I. A., Goroshkov N. P. Tyurkizm i pantyurkizm v original’nykh istochnikakh i mirovoy istoriografii: iskhodnyye smysly i tseli, paradoksy interpretatsiy, tendentsii razvitiya [Turkism and pan-Turkism in original sources and world historiography: initial meanings and goals, paradoxes of interpretations, development trends]. As-Alan. 2003. No. 1 (10). P. 3–478. (In Russ.).
5. Lugovoy G. A. Integratsionnyy potentsial pantyurkizma na primere vneshney i vnutrenney politiki Turtsii [The integration potential of pan-Turkism ideology]. Vestnik RGGU. Seriya: Politologiya. Istoriya. Mezhdunarodnyye Otnosheniya. Zarubezhnoye regionovedeniye. Vostokovedeniye. RGGU Bulletin. Series Political Science. History. International Relations. Area Studies. Oriental Studies. 2012. No. 1. P. 144–151. EDN: OUJVAZ. (In Russ.).
6. Goroshkov N. P. Pantyurkizm: genezis i evolyutsiya (istorikopolitologicheskiy analiz) [Pan-Turkism: genesis and evolution (historical and political analysis)]. Acta Orientalia Voronensia. Voronezhskoye vostokovedeniye. Acta Orientalia Voronensia. Voronezh Oriental Studies / ed. by M. V. Kirchanov. Voronezh, 2017. Vol. 2. P. 114–135. EDN: ZBDYSD. (In Russ.).
7. Senyutkina O. N. Tyurkizm kak istoricheskoye yavleniye (na materialakh istorii Rossiyskoy imperii 1905–1916 gg.) [Turkism as a historical phenomenon (based on the materials of the History of the Russian Empire, 1905–1916)]. Nizhniy Novgorod, 2007. 518 p. ISBN 978-5-9756-0022-6. (In Russ.).
8. Svarants A. A. Osnovnyye polozheniya pantyurkizma [Basic points of pan-Turkist] // Rossiyskiy pravovoy portal: biblioteka Pashkova. Russian Legal Portal: Pashkov Library. 2017. URL: https://constitutions.ru/?p=12196 (accessed: 16.06.2025). (In Russ.).
9. Shumilov M. M. Vliyaniye pantyurkizma na formirovaniye politicheskoy identichnosti tyurkoyazychnykh gosudarstv Tsentral’noy Azii v XXI veke. Chast’ 1 [The influence of panTurkism on the political identity formation of the Turkic states of Central Asia in the XXI century (Part 1)]. Upravlencheskoye konsul’tirovaniye. Administrative Consulting. 2022. No. 6. P. 36–53. DOI: 10.22394/1726-1139-2022-6-36-53. EDN: NWUFXP. (In Russ.).
10. Burashnikova A. B. Neopantyurkizm i neoosmanizm vo vneshney politike Turtsii [Neopan-Turkism and Neo-Ottomanism in the foreign policy of Turkey]. Izvestiya Saratovskogo Universiteta. Novaya seriya. Seriya: Istoriya. Mezhdunarodnyye otnosheniya. Izvestiya of Saratov University. History. International Relations. 2013. No. 2. P. 65–69. EDN: ROCXNF. (In Russ.).
11. Mekhdiyev E. T. «Neoosmanizm» v regional’noy politike Turtsii [“Neo-Ottomanism” in the regional policy of Turkey]. Vestnik MGIMO-Universiteta. MGIMO Review of International Relations. 2016. No. 2 (47). P. 32–39. EDN: VWVFMN. (In Russ.).
12. Avatkov V. A., Sbitneva A. I. Novyy natsionalizm Turetskoy Respubliki [New nationalism of Turkish republic]. Vestnik Rossiyskogo universiteta druzhby narodov. Ser. Politologiya. RUDN Journal of Political Science. 2022. Vol. 24, no. 2. P. 291– 302. DOI: 10.22363/2313-1438-2022-24-2-291-302. EDN: GPTYSE. (In Russ.).
13. Nadein-Rayevskiy V. A. Pantyurkizm v ramkakh ideologicheskoy ekspansii Turetskoy Respubliki [Pan-Turkism within framework of ideological expansion of Turkish republic]. Blizhniy i postsovetskiy Vostok. Middle & Post-Soviet East. 2024. No. 1 (5). P. 17–24. DOI: 10.31249/j.2949-2408.2024.01.02. EDN: BKMKHC. (In Russ.).
14. Avatkov V. A., Guzayerov R. I. Evraziystvo v Turtsii: vzglyad na Rossiyu i formirovaniye sobstvennoy paradigmy [Eurasianism in Turkey: A look at Russia and the formation of its own paradigm]. Kontury global’nykh transformatsiy: politika, ekonomika, pravo. Outlines of Global Transformations: Politics, Economics, Law. 2024. Vol. 17, no. 4. P. 20–34. DOI: 10.31249/kgt/2024.04.02. EDN: LHLLTS. (In Russ.).
15. Avatkov V. A., Badranov A. Sh. «Pantyurkistskiy» aspekt v diskurse sovremennogo tatarskogo natsional’nogo dvizheniya [The pan-Turkist aspect within the discourse of the modern Tatar national movement]. Natsional’naya bezopasnost’. Nota Bene. 2014. No. 2 (31). P. 283–291. DOI: 10.7256/2073–8560.2014.2.10884. EDN: RZWDED. (In Russ.).
16. Avatkov V. A. Ideyno-tsennostnyy faktor vo vneshney politike Turtsii [Ideology and values in Turkey's foreign policy]. Vestnik MGIMO-Universiteta. MGIMO Review of International Relations. 2019. No. 12 (4). P. 113–129 DOI: 10.24833/2071-8160-2019-4-67-113-129. EDN: RAGRDD. (In Russ.).
17. Minasyan N. A. Instrumenty realizatsii pantyurkizma v sovremennoy turetskoy vneshney politike i ikh vospriyatiye osnovnymi regional’nymi i vneregional’nymi aktorami [Implementation instruments of pan-Turkism in modern Turkish foreign policy and their perception by key regional and extraregional actors]. Rossiya i mir: nauchnyy dialog. Russia and the World: Scientific Dialogue. 2025. No. 1 (15). P. 57–81. DOI: 10.53658/RW2025-4-1(15)-57-81. EDN: WFSTXK. (In Russ.).
18. Svarants A. A. Osnovnyye ugrozy interesam Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot ideologii i politiki pantyurkizma (vneshniye i vnutrenniye aspekty) [The major threats posed to the interests of the Russian Federation emanating from the pan-Turkic ideology and policy]. Region i mir. Region and the World. 2010. No. 1. P. 3–11. EDN: WOFBMX. (In Russ.).
19. Shakaryants S. E. Rossiya, Iran i Kitay ostanavlivali pantyurkizm v Sirii, no po suti brosili Armeniyu!? [Russia, Iran and China stopped pan-Turkism in Syria, but in fact abandoned Armenia?!]. Region i mir. Region and the World. 2023. No. 3. P. 9–15. EDN: PUZZOV. (In Russ.).
20. Avatkov V. A. Postsovetskoye prostranstvo i Turtsiya: itogi 30 let [The Post-Soviet space and Turkey: the results of 30 years]. Kontury global’nykh transformatsiy: politika, ekonomika, pravo. Outlines of Global Transformations: Politics, Economics, Law. 2021. No. 14 (5). P. 162–176. DOI: 10.23932/2542-0240-2021-14-5-8. EDN: QXRUHE. (In Russ.).
21. Andrukhin T. V. Politika Turtsii v Tsentral’noy Azii: itogi i perspektivy [Turkey’s policy in central Asia: results and prospects]. Problemy postsovetskogo prostranstva. Post-Soviet Issues. 2024. Vol. 11, no. 2. P. 126–137. DOI: 10.24975/2313-8920-2024-11-2126-137. EDN: EITABU. (In Russ.).
22. Sun’ Ch. Organizatsiya Tyurkskikh Gosudarstv i pantyurkizm: vchera, segodnya, zavtra [Organization of Turkic states and panTurkism: yesterday, today, tomorrow]. Obrazovaniye i pravo. Education and Law. 2023. No. 2. P. 357–361. DOI: 10.24412/20761503-2023-2-357-361. EDN: AYOGKT. (In Russ.).
23. Evstratov A. G. Al’ternativnaya Evraziya v teni yataganov: pantyurkizm kak faktor destabilizatsii geopoliticheskogo BRIKS [Alternative Eurasia in the shadow of the scimitars: Pan-Turkism as a factor of destabilization of the geopolitical BRICS] // Strany BRIKS: Strategii razvitiya i mekhanizmy sotrudnichestva v menyayushchemsya mire [BRICS Countries: Development Strategies and Cooperation Mechanisms in a Changing World]. In 2 Parts / responsible ed. M. A. Bulavina, V. I. Gerasimov. Moscow, 2024. Part 1. P. 95–98. ISBN 978-5-6051774-8-7. EDN: OIJYAH. (In Russ.).
24. Milyukova A. G., Kovaleva A. V., Valyulina E. V. Pantyurkizm i geopoliticheskaya identichnost’ na sovremennom Evraziyskom prostranstve: analiz reprezentatsiy v SMI [Pan-Turkism and geopolitical identity in Modern Eurasia: the analysis of representations in the media]. Mirovaya politika. World Politics. 2021. No. 1. P. 25–38. DOI: 10.25136/2409-8671.2021.1.34970. EDN: TSKQNU. (In Russ.).
25. Boyko S. I., Sokolova V. I. Protivostoyaniye politicheskoy politsii Kazanskoy gubernii ideyam panislamizma i pantyurkizma v 1908–1914 godakh [Confrontation of the Kazan province political police to the ideas of pan-Islamism and pan-Turkism in 1908–1914]. Vestnik Chuvashskogo universiteta. Gumanitarnyye nauki. Bulletin of the Chuvash University. 2017. No. 4. P. 33–37. EDN: ZXJCCN. (In Russ.).
26. Starostin A. N. Proyavleniya ideologii pantyurkizma i panislamizma v regionakh Urala i Sibiri na rubezhakh XIX–XX vekov [Manifestations of the ideology of pan–Turkism and pan-Islamism in the regions of the Urals and Siberia at the turn of the 19th–20th centuries]. Etnopanorama. Etnokonfessional’nyye Otnosheniya v Regional’nom Izmerenii. Orenburg, 2024. P. 128–143. ISBN 978-5-94162-258-0. EDN: CNJFZF. (In Russ.).
27. Korolev V. I. Panislamistskoye i pantyurkistskoye dvizheniye krymskikh tatar v nachale XX stoletiya [Panislamist and Pantyurkist motion of Crimean tatars at the beginning of XX century]. Problemy postsovetskogo prostranstva. Post-Soviet Issues. 2019. No. 6 (3). P. 308–316. DOI: 10.24975/2313-89202019-6-3-308-316. EDN: UUHMCZ. (In Russ.).
28. Guseva Yu. N., Senyutkina O. N. «Pantyurkizm» v arkhivnykh istochnikakh epokhi stalinizma (1944–1953) [“Pan-Turkism” in archival sources of Stalinism (1944–1953)]. Rossiyskaya istoriya. Russian History. 2023. No. 6. P. 122–130. DOI: 10.31857/ S2949124X23060135. EDN: PTFBXA. (In Russ.).
29. Kotyukova T. V. «Politicheskaya dela» v Turkestane v nachale XX v.: «Shpionomaniya» ili «Okhota na ved’m» [“Political Cases” in Turkestan in early 20th century: “Spy-mania” or “Witch-hunt”]. Islam v sovremennom mire. Islam in the Modern World. 2016. No. 12 (3). P. 155–176. DOI: 10.22311/2074-1529-2016-12-3-155-176. EDN: XFWCSJ. (In Russ.).
30. Yuzeyev A. N. Islamizm, tyurkizm i tatarizm kak komponenty obshchestvenno-politicheskogo soznaniya tatar nachala XX veka [Islamism, Turkism and Tatarism as components of socialpolitic consciousness tatars at the beginning of the XX century]. Islam v sovremennom mire. Islam in the Modern World. 2018. No. 14 (1). P. 173–182. DOI: 10.22311/2074-1529-2018-14-1-173-182. EDN: YVPUVS. (In Russ.).
31. Senyutkina O. N., Guseva Yu. N. Panislamizm i pantyurkizm v osmyslenii rossiyskikh chinovnikov [Pan-Islamism and panTurkism as understood by Russian officials (early 20th century)]. Novyy istoricheskiy vestnik. The New Historical Bulletin. 2019. No. 2. P. 21–36. DOI: 10.24411/2072-9286-2019-00010. EDN: DXKYEA. (In Russ.).
32. Senyutkina O. N. «Panislamizm s samogo vozniknoveniya na Kavkaze nosil okrasku pantyurkizma»: idei tyurkskogo i islamskogo edinstva v otsenkakh rossiyskoy vlasti v nachale XX veka [“Pan-Islamism from the very emergence in the Caucasus carried the coloring of pan-Turkism”: the ideas of Turkic and Islamic unity in the assessments of the Russian authorities in the early XX century]. Vestnik arkhivista. Herald of an Archivist. 2025. No. 1. P. 33–49. DOI: 10.28995/2073-0101-2025-1-33-49. EDN: SIRZRC. (In Russ.).
33. Aksenov K. E., Andreyev M. V. Gorodskaya simvolicheskaya politika i prostranstvennaya diffuziya geopoliticheskikh innovatsiy v Rossiyskoy Federatsii [Urban forms of spatial diffusion of geopolitical innovations in the Russian Federation]. Izvestiya Rossiyskoy akademii nauk. Seriya geograficheskaya. Izvestiya RAN. Seriya Geograficheskaya. 2021. No. 85 (6). P. 870–887. DOI: 10.3157/S2587556621060030. EDN: HZJZRM. (In Russ.).
34. Senyutkina O. N., Guseva Yu. N. «Panislamizm» i «pantyurkizm» v rossiyskom obshchestvenno-politicheskom diskurse kontsa XIX–pervoy treti XX vekov: metodologicheskiye razmyshleniya [“Pan-Islamism” and “Pan-Turkism” in Russian sociopolitical discourse from the late 19th through the first third of the 20th centuries: methodological reflections]. Novyy istoricheskiy vestnik. The New Historical Bulletin. 2024. No. 3 (81). P. 183–214. DOI: 10.54770/20729286_2024_3_183. EDN: TUJZFK. (In Russ.).
Review
For citations:
Gumerov M.M., Guseva J.N. Modern Russian historiography on pan-Turkism: Issues, narratives and research perspectives. Omsk Scientific Bulletin. Series Society. History. Modernity. 2026;11(1):46-54. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.25206/2542-0488-2026-11-1-46-54. EDN: CVEQII
Views:
154
JATS XML
Email this article 